Intro.
Some days, you just need a good movie to cheer you up. That's how I was feeling today, so I decided to watch a movie from my Netflix instant play list. Turns out they've posted quite a few Gene Autry films, so I'm pretty much in fangirl heaven. I chose Carolina Moon mainly because it was from 1940 (one of Gene's best years) and co-starred June Storey and Mary Lee. While the singing was superb, the storyline and the over-done Southern cliches were not.Overview
The film begins with Caroline Stanhope (June Storey) and her grandfather (Eddy Waller) on their way North to a rodeo, where they hope to ride their prize thoroughbred and win enough money to pay the back taxes on their plantation. At the rodeo they meet Gene and Frog, who tell them that a thoroughbred can't compete with cow-ponies. Of course, our guys are right and when the grandfather loses a large bet, he is forced to sell Gene his horse in order to pay. Unfortunately, Caroline has other ideas and gets the family (and the horse) back to Carolina and leave Gene and Frog holding the bag. Well, the boys head South (despite Frog claiming there's no such place as Carolina). Once there, it's clear that the Stanhopes aren't the only ones in danger of losing their plantation. Gene and Frog naturally decide to help (mostly Gene, because he's obviously falling for Caroline). The main problem is a guy named Henry Wheeler (Hardie Albright) who wants all the owners to sell him their plantations so that he in turn can sell them for a profit to a lumber company. Gene and Frog figure it out after a fox-hunt, a Steeplechase, and a challenge to a duel. Anyway, just when you think it's worked out (the plantation owners sell their timber rights and are able to keep their land), the bad guys add one more twist. I won't give it away, but let's just say that lumberjacks vs. cowboys makes for one great fight!Highlights
I couldn't help but laugh during this film, both at the intentionally funny parts and the not-so-intentional parts. There were good points, but also a few very bad ones. On the one hand, Gene is great. He's funny and handsome and at the top of his game. His singing is just as great as his other films, and there is plenty of it. Worthy of note are the title song, as well as "Dancing Dreams That Won't Come True", "Say Si Si" and a great one by Mary Lee: "Me and My Echo." There are some great action scenes too - I already mentioned the fight between cowboys and lumberjacks (good money on the cowboys, of course!) and the race sequence where Gene rides in a Steeplechase. And he's right, he does look silly in that jockey cap! Gene and Frog manage to have some great comedy bits too, especially at the rodeo where Frog's trying to pick up a girl. Finally, to wrap up the highlights was Gene's final showdown with Wheeler. I didn't think Gene could really intimidate people, but somehow he pulls it off here: "I've heard that word honor ever since I've been here. We have it out West too. Only we handle them a little different. We just start shootin'."
The hard parts to watch revolved around the Southern cliches. Although the highlight there was how Mary Lee stopped the fox hunt! Still, the Southern Colonel obsessed with telling stories of the Civil War and the poor portrayal of African-Americans was too over the top. I think I finally had enough when Frog tried to disguise himself as a "Mamie." Really, Frog? I had to remind myself that this film was in 1940 and I'm in 2010, but it's still troubling to watch.
Review
This was one of the few times where I wasn't sure just how I felt about a movie. I think overall, Carolina Moon is not one of Gene's best films. The golden parts are the singing, the few action scenes and the comedic banter between Gene and Frog. Other than that, it feels dated and unusual. I missed Gene being out West and look forward to the next film that takes him back to the prairie.