I had no idea Ernest Borgnine could be so lovable!
Intro.
I never really liked Ernest Borgnine before, probably because I had always seen him cast as bad guys, most notably as "Fatso" in From Here to Eternity. But the write-up of Marty in the television listings sounded simple but charming, so I gave it a shot. The write up said: Love comes to a shy, heavyset Bronx butcher. Oscars for Screenplay, Director, Lead Actor and Best Picture.Overview
Marty Piletti is a heavyset 34-year old butcher living at home with his mother. He's constantly reminded by his customers (mainly Italian-American wives and mothers) and family that all five of his siblings, both older and younger, are married. "You should be ashamed of yourself," most of the women say. But it's not like Marty can help it; "I've been looking for a girl every Saturday night of my life." And this Saturday is no different; he and his friend Angie (Joe Mantell) heed his mother's recommendation and go to a dance club called the Stardust Room. Marty gets the brush off from girls, as usual, and he gets a bit disheartened. Then something incredible happens - this fellow approaches him, explains that he's on a blind date with a girl who's a dog and he's met up with some girl and wants to ditch his date. He offers Marty $5 to take his place on the date, but Marty being a very kind hearted gentleman calls the guy out for being a huge jerk. The guy goes off and Marty sees the girl alone. She looks so fragile and sad and when she goes out onto the fire escape to cry, Marty follows her. She's not a dog at all, though she's not as attractive as some of the other women at the club. Her name is Clara (Betsy Blair) and pretty soon she and Marty are inseparable. They dance, they confide in each other, they go out for coffee and wind up talking for three hours. What they have in common is that they've both nearly given up on ever finding love. Yet here they are, a perfect match. That is, until Clara meets Mrs. Piletti and disagrees with the family situation - Mrs. Piletti's sister Catherine is being kicked out of her son and daughter-in-law's house because the two women can't get along. So Mrs. Piletti, who's been after Marty to get married, refuses to like the girl he's finally found. Marty's friends aren't any help either, saying that Clara's a dog. Angie even gets jealous because Marty won't be spending time with him anymore. Will Marty take a chance on Clara or will he let what might be his only chance for true love pass him by?
Highlights
As I said in the tagline, I had no idea that Ernest Borgnine could be so lovable. This is one of the few (and possibly the first) times he was cast against his bad-guy type. And he's wonderful! Right from the opening lines we can see how kind and patient he is, even against the constant barrage of "when are you gonna get married?" We can see his close relationship with his family, which makes his decision much harder. Borgnine does a great job and it's easy to see why he won Best Actor (though I would've been torn on the Committee because he was up against Frank Sinatra in The Man with the Golden Arm).
What works so well is the simplicity of this story. A reviewer on IMDb wrote that this was the time when we didn't need special effects or action scenes to make a great and unforgettable story. And we don't just have the story of Marty and Clara. Just as impressive is the story of Aunt Catherine (Augusta Ciolli) and her fight with her daughter-in-law. Two women trying to rule the same house is difficult and it's a real shame that they can't get along. The fight that results between the daughter-in-law, Virginia, and her husband Tommy is realistic and an interesting perspective on married life. The scene where that fight unfolds is after they move Aunt Catherine into her sister Mrs. Piletti's house. They're on the porch and Marty's trying to ask Tommy about a business idea - he wants to buy the butcher's shop. He asks a question, but Tommy replies instead to Virginia about the situation with his mother. They finally leave, telling Marty that he's stupid to want to get married. Meanwhile we also get this lovely exchange between sisters Catherine and Teresa (Mrs. Piletti). They talk about growing old and feeling unloved and unwanted by their children. For these women, their children were their whole lives and although they are happy to see them married, they are also facing loneliness. The heart of the film lies in this loneliness, both for the women and for Marty and Clara, and how it can be overcome.
Clara is also really well played by Betsy Blair (who is anything but ugly, but made up to look less attractive). She has a college education, a loving home with her parents and a job offer waiting for her, but the one thing she wants most is the one thing she can't have. Her confession to Marty that she'd been to the Stardust Room before and sat alone for an hour and a half without a single dance request (guys even came to her table then changed their minds) is really important and truly heartbreaking.
I don't want to get too personal here, but watching this film made me feel better about myself. If Marty and Clara can find love, then so can anyone. That's what really made this film stand out to me - hope. There really is someone for everyone. It's what makes us human, this desire to love and be loved. No wonder it won best picture. Everyone can cheer for Marty and Clara.
Two stories to end with: First, although television was a huge threat to the film industry in the fifties, this film crossed the line between the media. Marty was originally a television drama featuring Rod Steiger. But Burt Lancaster's production company bought the rights and made it into a feature film. When it won Best Picture, the news left a big impact on the industry. Television wasn't just the low-class enemy anymore. And a funny story: I was on the phone with my friend Catherine trying to explain this story. She asked, well, how ugly is the guy who plays Marty? Is he really ugly? I said, "well, it's Ernest Borgnine, so...." I don't know that I'd call him the ugliest actor in Hollywood, but he's a very far cry from say, Cary Grant. However, Betsy Blair I think was too pretty to play a "dog". It also made me smile when she said no one would dance with her because her real life husband was Gene Kelly.
Review and Recommendation
I love this movie. I know I've already said that, but I want to say it again. I can always tell when I really liked a movie when I get really upset that it ends too soon. In this case, I wanted to see the rest of it - Marty and Clara dating more, getting married, having a family. But it was cut short! Still, the way it ends is probably Borgnine's finest moment on film. I definitely recommend Marty to everyone, especially to shy, single folks like me who have just reached the age when our group of single friends shrinks rapidly and we starting to get invitations to weddings. If Marty and Clara can find love, so can we!